You can get the book, American Prayers, free at this link!
(But it did take a lot of work to create, so any donation is appreciated!)!

A Sea Monster

From Bermuda, they write, that a Sea Monster has been lately seen there, the upper part of whose Body was in the Shape and about the Bigness of a Boy of 12 Years old, with long black Hair; the lower Part resembled a Fish. He was first seen on shore, and taking to the Water, was pursu’d by People in a Boat, who intended to strike him with a Fishgig; but approaching him, the human Likeness surpris’d them into Compassion, and they had not the Power to do it.

The Pennsylvania Gazette, April 29, 1736